Skip to main content
PRINT EDITION

Third-Party Sexual Harassment: The Challenge of Title IX Obligations for Law School Clinics

By March 1, 2021July 22nd, 2022No Comments

Abstract: Law faculty who teach and train students in clinical settings regularly expose students to the potential for sexual harassment. Because clinics involve actual cases in real-world contexts, students may encounter sexual harassment from third parties such as clients, witnesses, and judges. Do faculty who tolerate this exposure run afoul of their obligations under Title IX to stop and remedy sexual harassment about which they are, or should be, aware?

This Article is the first to identify and propose a method for addressing a phenomenon that strikes at the intersection of three sets of priorities for clinical faculty: duty to serve the client, duty to educate the student, and duty to protect the student. When a law student may face sexual harassment from a third party in the course of representing a client, the values underlying those priorities are in tension and admit no obvious solution; some remedies that Title IX arguably requires are, in many cases, impossible to square with the duties of loyalty and zealousness owed to a clinical client, not to mention the educational goals of the clinic. And yet, clinicians can and must embrace the fundamental principle of Title IX, which is to ensure that educational opportunities are available to all students, regardless of sex or gender presentation. The dilemma explored here echoes the modern American cultural, educational, and legal shift toward protecting students from speech and conduct deemed harmful, but does so in a non-classroom setting where legal ethics and clinical pedagogy are complicating factors.

Download the Full Article

Other Articles from WLR Print Edition

October 1, 2023 in PRINT EDITION

After The Criminal Justice System

Abstract: Since the 1960s, the “criminal justice system” has operated as the common label for a vast web of actors and institutions. But as critiques of mass incarceration have entered…
Read More
October 1, 2023 in PRINT EDITION

One Crisis or Two Problems? Disentangling Rural Access to Justice and the Rural Attorney Shortage

Abstract: We have all seen the headlines: No Lawyer for Miles or Legal Deserts Threaten Justice for All in Rural America. There is a substantial body of literature, across disciplines…
Read More
October 1, 2023 in PRINT EDITION

Taking the Long Road: The Excessive Fines Clause as a Tool for Protecting Washington’s Unsheltered Population

Abstract: Over the last decade, Washington State has seen a substantial increase in its unhoused population and an increase in laws that harm this group. Many of these laws subject…
Read More