Abstract: This Article examines the often-overlooked practice of “selective performance” of standard form consumer contracts—where sellers permit employees to exercise discretion by waiving or modifying contractual terms to maintain customer satisfaction. While such flexibility can benefit consumers, it raises serious concerns about discrimination. Through both theoretical analysis and empirical evidence, this Article demonstrates that discretionary performance can disproportionately favor certain consumer groups, particularly along racial and gender lines, leading to biased and inequitable outcomes. Drawing on examples from diverse sectors, including retail, insurance, and mortgage services, the Article highlights how marginalized communities, especially Black consumers, frequently face harsher treatment and greater obstacles in the enforcement of contractual rights. In response, the Article proposes actionable strategies to mitigate bias in the performance of consumer contracts. These strategies include debiasing training, the implementation of more objective decision-making criteria, increased monitoring and accountability, diversifying personnel, and leveraging artificial intelligence to detect and prevent discriminatory patterns. Additionally, the Article explores how regulators can incentivize sellers to adopt these bias-reducing measures through a “safe harbor” framework. By integrating insights from psychology and institutional design, this Article offers a roadmap for promoting fairness and reducing discrimination in the performance of consumer contracts, ultimately advocating for a more equitable marketplace.
Abstract: In 2021, the United States Supreme Court issued a controversial opinion with the potential to constrict the standing doctrine. TransUnion v. Ramirez appeared to alter standing’s “concrete harm” requirement, which would…
Read More
Abstract: Over 150 years ago, the federal government signed a treaty promising the Navajo people a permanent home within the bounds of their ancestral homeland. To this day, that promise…
Read More
Abstract: Individuals with disabilities are continuously marginalized by a world tailored to the able-bodied. One of the most visible areas where this marginalization manifests is employment. The Americans with Disabilities…
Read More